Reading and Analyzing Qualitative Components Influencing Spatial Perception in Traditional Houses of Yazd (A Comparative Study of Rasoulian House and Mortaz House)
Subject Areas : Application of the basics of Islamic urban planning and architecture in contemporary architecturesomayeh omidvari 1 * , Somayeh Davoudi 2 , Hossein Mahdavipour Shahrbabak 3
1 - Associate Professor, Department of Art and Architecture, Science and Arts University, Yazd, Iran.
2 - Visiting Professor, Department of Architecture, National University of Skills (NUS), Tehran, Iran.
3 - Assistant Professor, Department of Architecture, Yazd University, Yazd, Iran.
Keywords: Components of Perception, Mortaz House, Quality of perception, Perception of Space, Rasoulian House. ,
Abstract :
With the expansion of the field of architecture and its connection with other fields such as behaviorism and environmental psychology, topics such as the process of perception and the analysis of the components affecting it have drawn the attention of many researchers. Different theorists including "Lang", "Cremona" and "Ian Bentley" expressed different theories in the field of environmental perception and examined the components affecting qualitative perception and things like readability, variety, vitality, flexibility, sense Place and... have been presented in the explanation of qualitative components. While introducing the quality measurement models based on these theories, this article deals with the extraction and selection of the most effective components on the perception of space. In this research, which is of a mixed type, first among the components affecting the quality of perception, four components "variety, readability, visual compatibility and sensory richness" which have been given special attention by most theorists, were initially selected and While describing and analyzing the quality of each of the selected components, qualitative indicators such as geometry, order, fluidity, balance, evocativeness, etc. were extracted. Because these indicators can be evaluated in the measurement of qualitative perception; In the second part of the article, the impact of the components and indicators was measured using the questionnaire method and the average analysis of the obtained statistical data. In the following, with the aim of measuring and evaluating the mentioned indicators in the qualitative perception of two traditional houses in the historical context of Yazd, namely " Rasoulian" and " Mortaz", which in recent decades have become parts of the Yazd Faculty of Art and Architecture. Qualitative and quantitative measurements have been identified and analyzed in order to identify and accurately analyze the perceptual differences in these two houses. The respondents of the questionnaire of this research were graduates of Yazd Faculty of Art and Architecture who had the experience of attending these two houses for consecutive years and gained a relatively accurate understanding of these two houses. The analyzes have shown the perceptual commonalities in these two houses. Relying on the quantitative measurements, the findings of the article confirm that from the perspective of the users, all four investigated components had a significant effect on the qualitative perception of the spaces of this two houses, and this is a sign of the secret of the dynamics and durability of traditional architecture of Yazd.
Keywords: Components of Perception, Mortaz House, Quality of perception, Perception of Space, Rasoulian House.
Introduction
The field of architecture has undergone significant transformation over the years, evolving from a discipline primarily concerned with aesthetics and construction techniques to one that actively incorporates insights from behavioral science, environmental psychology, and sociology. This interdisciplinary approach has led to a deeper understanding of spatial perception and the Components influencing it. The Perception of Space, which refers to the way humans cognitively and sensorially interpret their surroundings, plays a critical role in how architectural spaces are experienced, appreciated, and utilized. In recent decades, researchers and theorists such as Kevin Lynch, Matthew Carmona, and Ian Bentley have contributed extensively to this field, offering frameworks and theories that identify multiple key qualitative components effecting spatial perception. These components, including legibility, diversity, vitality, flexibility, and a sense of place, are foundational to creating spaces that resonate with users on cognitive, emotional, and sensory levels.
This study delves into these theoretical insights by focusing on the Traditional Houses of Yazd, a city renowned for its ingenious desert-adaptive designs and historic urban fabric. Yazd’s traditional houses exemplify a harmonious blend of functional and aesthetic elements, offering a wealth of insights into how architecture can show environmental challenges while fostering a profound connection with its inhabitants. The research specifically examines and studies two exemplary traditional houses—Rasoulian House and Mortaz House—to explore the qualitative components influencing spatial perception. By conducting a comparative analysis, the study seeks to uncover the principles underlying the timeless appeal and enduring vitality of these architectural masterpieces.
Theoretical Foundations and Methodology
The Central part to this research is the identification and analysis of key qualitative components that effect on spatial perception. Based on a comprehensive review of theoretical literature and information, four components have been selected for detailed exploration: diversity, legibility, visual compatibility, and sensory richness. These components are frequently emphasized in the works of leading theorists and are considered essential in shaping meaningful and engaging architectural spaces. Each component is analyzed to extract specific attributes that contribute to spatial quality. For instance:
- Diversity: Refers to the variety and complexity of spatial arrangements, including variations in scale, function, and spatial transitions.
- Legibility: Encompasses the clarity and coherence of spatial organization, ensuring that users can easily navigate and understand the environment.
- Visual Compatibility: Highlights the harmonious integration of architectural elements, materials, and motifs to create aesthetically pleasing spaces.
- Sensory Richness: Focuses on the stimulation of multiple senses through elements such as light, texture, sound, and temperature.
The research adopts a mixed-methods approach, combining qualitative and quantitative techniques to provide a comprehensive understanding of spatial perception. In the qualitative phase, detailed analyses of the selected components are conducted through site visits, architectural documentation, and interpretative studies. Attributes such as geometry, order, fluidity, balance, and memorability are explored to understand how these components contribute to the overall spatial experience.In the quantitative phase, structured questionnaires are distributed to users and occupants of two Case Studies:Rasoulian House and Mortaz House. The survey captures subjective experiences and perceptions, providing statistical data that complements the qualitative findings. The combination of these methods ensures a robust analysis of how qualitative components influence spatial perception in traditional houses.
Case Studies: Rasoulian House and Mortaz House
Rasoulian House and Mortaz House were selected as case studies due to their exemplary representation of Yazd’s traditional architecture. Both houses, situated within the city’s historic fabric, embody the principles of adaptive design, cultural expression, and environmental harmony. Despite their differences in architectural spaces and historical contexts, both houses offer valuable insights into the qualitative aspects of spatial perception.
Rasoulian House
Rasoulian House is renowned for its central courtyard design, which exemplifies the traditional Persian architectural approach to creating a microclimate in hot and dry environments. The house features symmetrical layouts, intricate stucco work, and a well-defined spatial hierarchy. The courtyard acts as the focal point, surrounded by iwans (semi-open spaces), closed rooms, and subspaces. The interplay of light and shadow in the courtyard, coupled with the presence of water features and greenery, gives the space a sensory richness. The use of traditional materials such as adobe, brick, and plaster further adds to the tactile and visual appeal of the house.
Mortaz House
Mortaz House, though distinct in its design, shares several similarities with Rasoulian House in terms of its adaptive use of spatial elements. The house is characterized by its geometric precision, balance, and functional layout, which reflect a strong focus on legibility. The clear spatial hierarchy and axial alignments make the house easily navigable, while the harmonious integration of architectural elements ensures visual consistency. The use of semi-open spaces, such as iwans and porches, allows for a seamless transition between indoor and outdoor environments, enhancing the overall spatial experience.
Findings and Implications
The findings of this study highlight the significant role of the four identified components in shaping spatial perception. Diversity, legibility, visual compatibility, and sensory richness are shown to have a substantial impact on how users experience and interpret the spaces in two traditional houses:Rasoulian House and Mortaz House. Attributes such as geometry, order, fluidity, balance, and memorability further enhance the qualitative richness of these environments.The perceptual commonalities observed between the two houses underscore the effectiveness of traditional architectural principles in creating meaningful and engaging spaces. These principles, rooted in a deep understanding of human needs and environmental context, have contributed to the enduring vitality and resilience of Yazd’s traditional architecture. The findings also provide valuable insights for contemporary architectural practices, emphasizing the importance of integrating qualitative components into Contemporary design processes.
Lessons for Contemporary Architecture
This research underscores the relevance of traditional architectural principles in showing contemporary challenges. By drawing inspiration from the qualitative components analyzed in this study, architects can create spaces that are both functional and meaningful. For instance, incorporating elements of diversity in spatial arrangements can enhance user engagement and adaptability, while ensuring legibility can improve the navigability and coherence of spaces. Similarly, both emphasizing visual compatibility and sensory richness can create environments that foster a sense of place, community, and well-being.
In conclusion, this study confirms that the qualitative components analyzed are integral to the spatial perception of Yazd traditional houses. These components enhance the aesthetic, functional, and emotional qualities of the spaces, contributing to their enduring relevance in contemporary architectural discourse. The lessons learned from Rasoulian House and Mortaz House highlight the potential of traditional architectural principles to inform and inspire future design practices, ensuring the creation of spaces that resonate with users on multiple levels.
Refrences
Atkinson, R. L. (2014). Psychology of sensation and perception (H. EbrahimiMoghadam, Trans., 2nd ed.). Tehran: Farabi Publications. (Original work published in Persian)
Pak Nehad, H., &Pajoohanfar, M. (2017). Improving spatial quality patterns of urban parks to enhance social interactions among citizens: A case study of parks in Gorgan. Golestan University Quarterly Journal, 7(26), 22–55. (Original work published in Persian)
Paykan, E., &Rafieian, M. (2019). In search of an integrated framework for spatial perception in interactive studies of human and environment. Armanshahr Architecture and Urban Development, 28, 125–138. (Original work published in Persian)
Shahcheraghi, A., &Bandarabad, A. (2020). Enclosed in the environment (Application of environmental psychology in architecture and urban planning). Tehran: Jihad Daneshgahi Organization Publications. (Original work published in Persian)
Tahmasebi, A., Alizadeh, H., &Aslani, P. (2018). A study of the components shaping the semantic-perceptual quality of the environment: A case study of the Gatarcheenan neighborhood in Sanandaj. Armanshahr Architecture and Urban Development, 25. (Original work published in Persian)
KamuShalmani, K., &Hanachi, S. (2015). Examining the impact of visual factors in urban spaces on citizens' behavioral patterns: A case study of Rasht Municipality Square. City Identity, 24. (Original work published in Persian)
آتکینسون، ریتا ال (1393) زمینه روانشناسی احساس و ادراک، مترجم: حسین ابراهیمیمقدم، چاپ دوم، تهران، فارابی.
اسدی، علی و سعید صالحی مرزیجرانی و حسن سجادزاده و حسین کلانتری خلیلآباد (1402) نقش کیفیت محیطی در تداوم سکونت و زندگی در مجتمعهای زیستی شهر اراک، نشریه مطالعات شهری، پیاپی 47، صص 19-32.
بادآهنگ، ابوالفضل و حسین کلانتری خلیلآباد و کرامتالله زیاری (1401) شناسایی و تبیین پیشرانهای کلیدی مؤثر بر کیفیت منظر در بافتهای تاریخی شهرها (مطالعه موردی: محله سنگ سیاه شهر شیراز)، نشریه مطالعات شهر ایرانی اسلامی، پیاپی 50، صص 37-50.
براتی، ناصر، کاکاوند، الهام (1392) ارزیابی تطبیقی کیفیت محیط سکونت شهری با تأکید بر تصویر ذهنی شهروندان، نشریه هنرهای زیبا، شماره 3، صص 25-32.
براتی، ناصر و محمدعلی سلیماننژاد (1390) ادراک محرکها در محیط کنترلشده و تأثیر جنسیت بر آن، باغ نظر، شماره 17، صص 19-29.
بنتلي، اياين و آلن الكك و پال مورين و مكگلين و سوواسميت گراهام (1382) محیطهاي پاسخده: کتاب راهنماي طراحان، ترجمه مصطفي بهزادفر، تهران، علم و صنعت.
بیطرف، سمیه و محسن کاملی و بهرام صالح صدقپور (1400) نقش مطالعات جغرافیای انسانی (عناصر محیط- رفتار) در بازشناسی الگوی آموزشی درس طراحی معماری 5 (مسکونی)، نگرشهای نو در جغرافیای انسانی، شماره 50، صص 22-55.
پاک نهاد، حدیثه و مهدیه پژوهانفر (1396) بهبود الگوهای کیفیت فضایی پارکهای شهری بهمنظور افزایش تعاملات اجتماعی شهروندان، نمونه موردی: پارکهای شهر گرگان، فصلنامه دانشگاه گلستان، سال هفتم، شماره 26، صص 22-55.
پاکزاد، جهانشاه (1385) مبانی نظری و فرآیند طراحی شهری، تهران، شهیدی.
پالاسما یوهانی (1395) خیال مجسم: تخیل و خیالپردازی در معماری، ترجمة علی اکبری، تهران، پرهام نقش.
پایکن، عصمت و مجتبی رفیعیان (1398) در جستوجوی چارچوب یکپارچه ادراک فضا در مطالعات تعاملی انسان و محیط، معماری و شهرسازی آرمان شهر، شماره 28، صص 125-138.
پورجعفر، محمدرضا و علیاکبر تقوایی و علیرضا صادقی (1388) خوانش تأثیر ساماندهی محورهای بصری بر ارتقاء کیفیت محیط فضاهای عمومی شهری (نمونه موردی: خیابان آزادی تهران)، مدیریت شهری، شماره 24.
حاجی قاسمی، کامبیز (1383) گنجنامه آثار تاریخی- خانههای سنتی یزد، تهران، روزنه.
خامنه، بتول و حسـن جنگـی (1393) تحلیـل فضـایی عملکــردهــاي زیباشناســانه در ایجــاد آرامــش روانــی شهروندان (نمونه موردي: منطقه 6 شـهرداري تهـران)، آمایش محیط، دوره 7 ، شماره 27.
داداشپور، هاشم، روشنی، صالح (1392) ارزیابی تعامل میان فرد و محیط زندگی در محلات جدید با استفاده از سنجش کیفیت عینی و ذهنی؛ مطالعه موردی: شهرک نفت تهران، مطالعات شهری، صص 3-15.
دوبران، اسماعیل و داود خدایی و سعید غلامی و مهرداد دانشدوست (1391) سنجش مؤلفههای آسایش بصری در منظر شهری (با تأکید بر محله حسنیه اعظم زنجان)، نشریه جغرافیا و مطالعات شهری، دوره 1، شماره 3، پاییز، تهران.
راستبین، ساجد و یاسر جعفری و یاسمن دارم و امیرمحمد معززی مهر طهران (1391) رابطه همبستگی بین کیفیتهای محیطی و تداوم حیات شهری در عرصههای عمومی(نمونه موردی: جلفای اصفهان)، باغ نظر، سال نهم، شماره 21، صص 35-46.
رضازاده، راضیه، مصطفی عباسزادگان و صهبا گلچینفر (1384) عوامل مؤثر بر تعامل اجتماعی در فضاهای باز شهری، شهرداریها، صص 58-61.
رضایی، حسین و غزال کرامتی و مزین دهباشی شریف و محمدرضا نصیرسلامی (1397) تبیین الگووارهای فرآیند روانشناختی حصول معنای محیطی و تحقق حس مکان با تمرکز بر نقش واسط ادراک.
باغ نظر، 15(65 )، صص 49-66.
رفیعیان، مجتبی و مریم عظیمی و حامد مقدم (1391) ارزیابی کیفیت مناطق شهری در برخورداری از فضاهای عمومی با استفاده از نمودار وزنی و رونی؛ نمونه موردی شهر قدیم لار، آمایش محیط، شماره 16، صص 33-50.
زنگنه، نجمه و هادی کشمیری (1397) نقش مؤلفههای غنای حسی در ارتقاء کیفیت محیطی فضای شهری (نمونه موردی: مجموعه زندیه شیراز)، مجله جغرافیا و توسعه فضای شهری، سال پنجم، شماره 2.
سعیدیان، عبدالحسین (1388)، دوره ده جلدی دایرهالمعارف بزرگ نو، جلد اول، تهران، علم و زندگی- آرام.
شاهچراغی، آزاده و علیرضا بندرآباد (1399) محاط در محیط (کاربرد روانشناسی محیطی در معماری و شهرسازی)، تهران، سازمان جهاددانشگاهی.
شاهی آقبلاغی، عارف و یعقوب زنگنه و حسن خدابنده لو، و عباس درودینیا (1395) سنجش شاخصهای کیفیت محیط شهری (مطالعه موردی: مسکن مهر شهر سبزوار).
مطالعات جغرافیایی مناطق خشک، دوره 7، شماره 26، صص 54-72.
شرفی، علی و شرف مطوب و سعیده اسدی (1396) «تحلیل نقش ادراک خطر بر رفتار محیطی هنگام لرزه در مجموعه گنجعلیخان و بازار کرمان»، فصلنامه مطالعات شهر ایرانی اسلامی، شماره 28، تابستان، تهران.
شریفیان، محمدامین و نیر طهوری و ایرج اعتصام و حسین ذبیحی (1398) مطالعه تطبیقی پدیدارشناسی معماری در نظریات یوهانی پالاسما و استیون هال.
کیمیای هنر، 8 (33)، صص 63-80.
شفیعی، روشنک و پرویز شریفی درآمدی (1385) نابینایی و ادراک محیط، تهران، سپاهان.
شمس اسفندآباد، حسن، (1393)، روانشناسی محیط، تهران، سمت.
صالحینیا، مجید و مهدیه نیرومند شیشوان (1397) تبیین نقش مؤلفههای منظر حسی مبتنی بر حواس در کیفیت ادراک حسی محیطی گذر ارگ جدید تبریز، فصلنامه شهر ایرانی اسلامی، 8(31)، صص 19-31.
صداقت، زهرا (1396) سنجش غنای حسی فضاهای شهری: معرفی یک چارچوب تحلیلی، مجله صفه، دوره 27، شماره 1.
طهماسبی، ارسلان و هوشمند علیزاده و پرویز اصلانی (1397) مطالعه مؤلفههای شکلدهنده کیفیت معنایی- ادراکی محیط، مورد مطالعاتی: محله قطارچینان سنندج، معماری و شهرسازی آرمان شهر، شماره 25.
کامو شلمانی، کامور و سیمین حناچی (1394) بررسی تأثیر عوامل بصری فضاهای شهری بر الگوهای رفتاری شهروندان (مطالعه موردی: میدان شهرداری رشت)، هویت شهر، شماره بیست و چهارم.
کریمی یزدی، اعظم و ناصر براتی و مجید زارعی (1395) ارزیابی تطبیقی ادراک فضای شهری از نظرگاه مخاطبین و متخصصین عرصه شهری (مطالعه موردی مجموعه شهری امامزاده صالح تجریش تهران)، باغ نظر، شماره 45.
گلکار، کورش (1379) مؤلفههای سازنده کیفیت طراحی شهری، دانشگاه شهید بهشتی، نشریه صفه، شماره 32، صص 38-65.
لنگ، جان (1390) آفرینش نظریه معماری نقش علوم رفتاری در طراحی محیط، ترجمه علیرضا عینیفر، دانشگاه تهران.
مطلبی، قاسم (1380) روانشناسی محیطی دانشی نو در خدمت معماری و طراحی شهری، هنرهای زیبا، شماره 10، صص 52-67.
مک اندرو، فرانسیس تی (1387) روانشناسی محیطی، ترجمه غلامرضا محمودی، تهران، زرباف اصل.
نقیزاده، محمد (1382) مبانی فلسفی زیباییشناسی طراحی محیط و منظر ایرانی، محیطشناسی، شماره 30، صص 61-80.
Hazreena, Hussein (2010) “Using the sensory garden as a tool to enhance the educational development and social interaction of children with special needs”, Support for learning, volume 25, number 1. Pp 25-41.
Makachia, P. (2015) Influence of house form on dweller- initiated transformations in urban housing.
Chen, Sidi (2024) Exploring the Relationship Between Architectural Space Perception and User Experience in the Construction Industry Using Digital Art, Computer-Aided Design & Applications, 21(S11), 28-41.
Higuera-Trujillo, J.L.; linares, C.; Macagno, E. (2021) TheCognitive-Emotional Design andStudy of Architectural Space:A Scoping Review ofNeuroarchitecture and Its PrecursorApproaches. Sensors,21.
Ghadiri, M., &Shahrbabaki, S. (2016) Comparativeanalysis of the quality of reconstructed urban servicesand visage in Bam city. Barnamerizi-ye Shahri, 7 (25),173-190.